Porsche

Company Info  Back to new car index  
 

Porsche 911 Turbo

Related models : 911 Carrera and GT3
Picture Gallery: - Related topics: VTG turbo911 Turbo (1975-89)996 Turbo
Versions included here: General,  GT2
.
30 years after the launch of the first 911 Turbo, the Turbo is still a senior core member of the 911 family. Throughout the years, 911 Turbo evolved from 3.0 to 3.6 litres, single turbo to twin-turbo, from mechanical wastegate to electronic boost control, from 260 horsepower to 420 horsepower, rear-drive to all-wheel-drive…. Watching the evolution of this car just like studying the history of automotive technology. Today, the 996 Turbo is an astonishingly quick and refined sports car. Many people say it is close to perfect. What can be improved? The answer from Weissach is: even more power and even more refinement.

Before introducing the 997 Turbo, let us talk about the market positioning of this car. Priced at £100,000 in the UK market, the Turbo rivals Ferrari F430 (£120,000) and Lambo Gallardo (£120,000), although luxury grand tourers like Aston Martin DB9 (£110,000), BMW M6 (£80,000) and Mercedes SL55 / 65 AMG (£100,000 / £150,000) may also present threats. Besides, there is internal competition from 911 GT3 (£80,000) and GT2 (est £130,000). However, both the GT3 and GT2 are lightweight road and track dual-purpose sports cars aimed at very hardcore drivers, while the Turbo is a pure road car for daily use. It has more luxury features and sound-deadening than both, not to mention the all-weather security from its 4WD system.

997 Generation

As in the case for Carrera, the 997 Turbo is a small evolution from 996 Turbo, unlike the mutation from 993 to 996. Outside, the most obvious change is the return to traditional round headlamps. Then you can see it has many ventilation holes enlarged for better cooling, while the bi-plane electric rear spoiler has been widened. As a result, aerodynamic lift has been reduced slightly while drag coefficient remains unchanged at 0.31.

The 997's steel monocoque chassis is believed to be slightly stiffer than the last generation. It also gains 22mm in width to enhance cornering prowess. The suspensions get electronic adaptive damping like the Carrera. The brakes have been enlarged from 330mm to 350mm all round, with 6-pot front and 4-pot rear calipers. As before, ceramic composite brakes are optional (they cost some £6,000 !). Another major improvement is the 4WD system. Previously it employed a passive viscous coupling to send torque to the front wheels when the rear wheels slip. Now it is replaced by an electronic-controlled multi-plate clutch. This mean the PTM (Porsche Traction Management) program can redistribute power between the front and rear axle at any time to correct undesirable under / oversteer.

These enhancements inevitably add weight. Although Porsche compensates with the use of aluminum doors, the new Turbo still got an extra 45 kilograms, taking the kerb weight to 1585 kg. That is 135 kg heavier than the all-aluminum Ferrari F430, but still comfortably lighter than other grand tourers like BMW M6 and Aston Martin DB9.

Every time Porsche allowed weight increase must accompany with even more gain in power. The 997 Turbo is no exception. Although its 24-valve water-cooled boxer engine keeps capacity unchanged at 3600cc (we predicted it to grow to 3.8 litres), as is the Variocam-Plus variable valve timing and lift system, it gets a pair of new variable geometry turbochargers developed by BorgWarner (which acquired KKK in 1998). It is said to be the world's first VTG turbo for petrol engines, whose exhaust gas is much hotter than diesel engines thus requires specially-developed, heating-resisting vanes. The variable exhaust vane geometry makes better use of the exhaust flow regardless of rpm, thus improve turbo response at low rev and increase power at high rev.

As a result, the 3.6-litre twin-turbo engine pumps out 480 horsepower at 6000 rpm, 60 horses up from the 996 Turbo, or just 3 horses shy of the outgoing GT2. The new engine is also much more torquey and flexible. It produces 457 lbft from 1950-5000 rpm, versus the old car's 413 lbft / 2700-4600 rpm. If this is not enough, an optional Sport program offers a 10-second overboost of 0.2 bar, taking the max torque to 501 lbft for strong overtaking.

With the stronger engine, the new Turbo can run to 193mph (up from 190mph), accelerate from 0-60mph in 3.8 seconds (down from 4.1 sec) and 0-124mph in 12.8 seconds (down from 14.5 sec). Quite unbelievably, Porsche claims the car equipped with 6-speed Tiptronic S automatic transmission is even quicker – 0-60mph in 3.6 sec and 0-124mph in 12.2 sec. This is because the computers of the gearbox and VTG turbochargers can communicate with each other to optimize acceleration.

On the Road

The beauty of 911 Turbo is the combination of astonishing speed and handling with an easily livable manner. It satisfies the definition of super sports cars and grand tourers simultaneously. Apart from the recent Ferrari 599GTB, I can't think of any other cars have such achievement.

The 997 Turbo is very fast, no question. There are not many cars on this planet can do 0-60mph in 3.8 seconds and 0-100mph under 9 seconds. Ferrari F430 can. Lamborghini Gallardo cannot. Even the mighty 959 supercar is eclipsed by it, although you might ask why the Turbo took 20 years of development to do so.

Porsche's twin-turbo flat-six is very different from its rivals' naturally-aspirated V8 or V10. It sounds subdued, even too quiet for a sports car. But it generates massive torque from very low rpm and carry on until 6000rpm. The wide power band means you don't need to rev it to deliver performance. The VTG turbochargers have virtually no lag. The boxer engine runs smoothly. It does not appear to have any temper, just work quietly and efficiently to push the car forward. No doubt it is a German product.

Handling can be summarized in a few words: massive grip, fool-proof traction, first-class braking, excellent body control and composure. For sure, 911 Turbo is not a lightweight, but it hides its weight very well. Its compact size is a strong card in narrow twisties. Its strong brakes are confidence inspiring, as is the accurate and meaty steering. Rearward weight bias seems totally irrelevant to its excellent dynamic balance, thanks to the 40 years of experience of tuning its suspensions, tires and traction system. Yes, its handling is not as sharp as GT3, but its cornering prowess is equally high and definitely more secured, thanks to the clever 4-wheel-drive system. On wet surfaces or roads you are not familiar with, the Turbo is always the best companion to go with.

On the other hand, the 911 Turbo is also a very comfortable grand tourer. Its PASM adaptive suspensions has the choice of comfort mode and sport mode to suit different purposes. In comfort mode, ride compliance can shame many high-performance grand tourers such as BMW M6 and Aston DB9.

Then there is a spacious cabin, the luxury features (power seats and windows, climate control, sound and navigation system, leather upholstery) and plenty of luggage space (in case you fold down the dog seats). The Turbo is a comfortable long-distance GT.

That said, there is something missing in the car – emotion. Compare to Ferrari F430 or Lamborghini Gallardo, the Porsche turbocharged flat-6 is too civilized in the way it sings and the way it responds to throttle input. It is therefore less inspiring to drive. Ditto the 4WD handling, which is probably too safe. Remove some understeer and add some more feel to the steering will bring more excitement. But then you know Porsche has already got such car – GT3. As we always know, for pure driving pleasure there is no replacement to a naturally aspirated engine and rear-wheel drive.
 
The above report was last updated on 22 Jun 2006. All Rights Reserved.

911 GT2


More power and less weight distinguish GT2 from Turbo...

Since its introduction in 1995, GT2 has been at the top of the 911 family tree. Its philosophy is simple: derived from 911 Turbo, but with more power and less weight. In other words, GT2 is a stripped-out version of the Turbo, so lean that even the fool-proof 4-wheel-drive system has to be deleted. The first generation GT2 was based on the air-cooled 993 and provided 430 horsepower out of 1290 kilograms of kerb weight. It was so named because it was designed to compete in FIA GT2 category. People got excited about its speed as well as its sharper handling, so it set a successful formula for the following generations. The second generation, 996-based GT2 arrived in 2001 with 462 horsepower and 1440 kg (upgraded to 483 hp since 2003). Unfortunately, it wasn't so good to drive because the setting was too soft and too understeer-biased.

Having learned the lesson, things should get better in the third incarnation, 997 GT2. Again, it has more power than the Turbo. While the engine is still that 3.6-liter flat-six with variable geometry twin-turbo, it employs a ram-air intake at the rear spoiler, a lower back-pressure exhaust and, take note, a new expansion-type intake manifolds. What is the latter ? Its theory is simple: increases the turbo boost by 0.2 bar --> the compressed air gets hotter --> use a larger intercooler to cool down the air --> the air is expanded back to normal boost pressure in the intake manifolds --> due to the expansion, the intake air flow cools down and gets denser, improving volumetric efficiency. As a result, the GT2 engine pumps out 530 horsepower or 50 horses more than the Turbo. Its maximum torque increases by 44 lb-ft to 501 lb-ft. This is the first time a 911 exceeded 500 horsepower, also the first time its top speed exceeded 200 mph, or exactly at 204 mph. Remarkably, the expansion type intake actually improves fuel economy from the old car's 21.8 mpg to 22.6 mpg. Do more, drink less, this is the way our cars should point to.

The new GT2 also worked harder to cut weight. Reverting to rear-wheel-drive saves it around 50 kg. Standard PCCB ceramic brakes save anther 20 kg. Switching to titanium exhaust system saves 9 kg. Then there are the usual leaner interior, lightweight carbon-fiber bucket seats, the deletion of rear seats, a glass-fiber engine lid and a lighter rear spoiler. Combining them results in 145 kilograms of loss compared with the Turbo (for reference, the last generation GT2 lost only 100 kg). At 1440 kg, it is only 45 kg more than the normally-aspirated GT3, while engine power overwhelms it by 115 hp. As everybody expected, the GT2 is easily the fastest 911 in history. Although the loss of 4-wheel-drive traction doesn't benefit initial acceleration, it is still claimed to do 0-60 mph in 3.6 seconds. However, more telling is 7.4 seconds to reach 100 mph, which put it comfortably ahead of Ferrari 430 Scuderia, Lamborghini Gallardo Superleggera, Dodge Viper and Ford GT, although the pricier Ferrari 599 GTB is quicker still.


Performance-wise, nothing else in the Porsche family compares to this car, but for driving excitement, its lesser brother GT3 has an upper hand...

To tame the power, Porsche fitted it with 325/30ZR19 rear tires - the widest tires ever appeared in a 911. Moreover, the GT2 is finally available with traction control and PSM stability control like the Turbo. PASM adaptive damping is also a first for the GT2. The suspension is fully adjustable for ride height, camber and caster. The ceramic brakes come directly from GT3, with 380 mm and 350 mm discs front and rear respectively. Outside, extra air dam, skirts and a fixed double-plane rear spoiler generate more downforce, although drag coefficient inevitably goes up from 0.31 to 0.32.

Porsche wants to make the new GT2 a faster version of the GT3. On the road, it is mostly successful. Walter Rohrl, the company's famous test driver, lapped Nurburgring Nordschleife in 7 min 32 seconds, 15 seconds quicker than the GT3, 14 seconds less than the last GT2 and actually ties with the mighty Carrera GT !! The sensation of speed comes from the powerful engine as well as a good handling. Unlike the old car, the new GT2 no longer understeers too much. Thanks to the safety net provided by traction control and stability control, Porsche could afford a neutral chassis tuning without worrying of disasters. As a result, the car feels better balanced and more eager to attack corners. Turn-in is sharp and the steering is full of feel. As you would expect, body control and braking are both first rate in the top 911 model. What you might not expected is a superb ride when the adaptive damping is in comfort mode. This mean you can exploit its performance more of the time and on a variety kinds of roads.

Does it have any weaknesses ? Not many, but there are still some. Firstly, the loss of 4WD makes the driving experience less confidence-inspiring than the Turbo. Although the subtle electronic aids are good enough to handle the worst situations, they are still no replacement to all-wheel traction. Advanced drivers always want to disable electronic aids and take full control by themselves. If they switch off the traction control and stability control in the new GT2, they will need to be very cautious not to let its power overrun the chassis, because that will be very difficult to rescue. After all, five hundred pound-foot of torque going through the rear wheels is no kidding.

Another problem of the GT2 is throttle response. Even this turbocharged engine is virtually free of turbo lag, it still can't match a good normally aspirated engine for instantaneous throttle response and therefore the ability to finely adjust the cornering attitude with throttle and steering. For this reason, keen drivers will always prefer GT3 to this car.

This lead to our final question: is the £131,000 GT2 worth so much money compare with the £80,000 GT3 and £98,000 Turbo ? The answer is simple. If you want a luxurious and versatile fast car, you had better to choose the Turbo. If you want the ultimate driving excitement, then GT3 must be the first choice. However, if all you need is the ultimate performance, especially in straight line, then nothing else come close to the GT2.


The above report was last updated on 14 Oct 2007. All Rights Reserved.

Specifications

Model
911 Turbo
911 Turbo Tiptronic
911 GT2
Layout
Rear-engined, 4wd
Rear-engined, 4wd
Rear-engined, Rwd
L / W / H / WB (mm)
4450 / 1852 / 1300 / 2350
4450 / 1852 / 1300 / 2350
4450 / 1852 / 1300 / 2350
Engine
Flat-6, dohc, 4v/cyl, VVT,
VTG twin-turbo.
Flat-6, dohc, 4v/cyl, VVT,
VTG twin-turbo.
Flat-6, dohc, 4v/cyl, VVT,
VTG twin-turbo, expansion induction.
Capacity
3600 cc
3600 cc
3600 cc
Power
480 hp
480 hp
530 hp / 6500 rpm
Torque
457 lbft (501 lbft overboost)
457 lbft (501 lbft overboost)
501 lbft / 2200-4500 rpm
Transmission
6M
6A
6M
Suspension (F/R)
strut / multi-link,
adaptive damping.
strut / multi-link,
adaptive damping.
strut / multi-link,
adaptive damping.
Tyres (F/R)
235/35ZR19 / 305/30ZR19
235/35ZR19 / 305/30ZR19
235/35ZR19 / 325/30ZR19
Weight
1585 kg
1620 kg
1440 kg
Top speed
193 mph (c)
193 mph (c)
204 mph (c)
0-60 mph (sec)
3.8 (c) / 3.6* / 3.4** / 3.4**
3.6 (c) / 3.3** / 3.4***
3.6 (c) / 3.4****
0-100 mph (sec)
8.0* / 8.8** / 8.0**
8.3** / 7.8***
7.4 (c) / 7.3****
AutoZine's rating
Click Here
Click Here
Click Here
See illustration to spec.
Figures tested by: * Autocar, ** R&T, *** C&D, **** MT
  .

Copyright© 1997-2007 by Mark Wan
Return to AutoZine home page