AutoZine's
Rating
Rules
Rules for
classification
As AutoZine includes
almost
all cars in the world, it is uneasy to classify all the cars into
different
categories. Basically, classification is made according to target
buyers
and price. It’s easy to understand how important is target buyers. For
instance, those interested in Lotus Elise are unlikely to love the
similarly-priced
Chevrolet Camaro because of completely different character, so they
won’t
be classified into the same category.
Another thing to be
noted
is price. There is price difference among different continents,
especially
is for exclusive high-performance cars. Whenever a price is being
considered,
it is always based on the retail price at the place where the car is
produced,
minus tax. Excessive retail / distribution cost is also taken into
consideration
because there are a few European countries having very inefficient
retail
system. After all, price is not the only important factor to the
buyers,
so there is up to ± 50% tolerance in some extreme cases.
Magnitude of
rating
      |
Perfect |
     |
Outstanding |
    |
Good |
   |
Average |
  |
Poor |
 |
Junk |
|
|

|
Eco bonus: for environmental-friendly cars
|
 |
AutoZine's pick of the class |
.
Rules for rating
Generally speaking,
cars
are assessed in these areas:
- Exterior and
interior
styling
- Engine and
performance
- Handling and ride
quality
- Comfort,
equipment,
practicality
and safety
- Build quality and
reliability
- Price and running
cost
- Originality and
innovation
In short, nothing special.
Different
kinds of cars may have different weighting in these areas, say, engine
and handling are the most important for sports car. As I am not
computer,
I won’t rate each items and calculate the total marks like Car and
Driver
or Road & Track. I really doubt if such "objective" calculation
will
result in the best choices to car enthusiasts. You know, that is the
way
Consumer Digest used to rate cars.
However, AutoZine
always
rate cars from enthusiastic driver’s point of view. Like British or
French
and unlike American, handling is usually regarded as more important
than
performance. Besides, the meaning of "handling" also differs from
American’s
view point as cornering g-force. Steering feel, steering tendency,
cornering
adjustability and precision of controls (brake, throttle, clutch,
gearchange)
are seen as most important.
Mini Cars
(A/B-segment)
|
|
| Citroen C2 |
   |
| Daewoo Matiz |
  |
| Daihatsu Mira /
Charade |
   |
Daihatsu Move
|
   |
Daihatsu Max
|
   |
| Fiat Panda |
    |
| Fiat 500 |
      |
| Ford Ka |
  |
| Honda Life /
That's |
   |
| Hyundai i10 |
   |
| Kia Picanto |
  |
| Mitsubishi i |
   |
| Mitsubishi eK Wagon |
  |
| Renault Twingo |
    |
| Smart Fortwo |
   |
Subaru R1 / R2
|
   |
| Suzuki Wagon R |
  |
| Suzuki MR Wagon |
  |
| Suzuki Lapin |
  |
| Suzuki Splash |
    |
| Toyota Aygo |
   |
|
|
|
| BMW Mini / Clubman |
    |
| Citroen C3 |
   |
Dacia Logan
|
   |
Daewoo Kalos
|
  |
| Fiat Palio |
  |
Fiat Grande Punto
|
      |
| Ford Fiesta |
   |
| Ford Fusion |
  |
Honda Fit (Jazz)
|
     |
Hyundai Getz
|
  |
Kia Rio / Hyundai Accent
|
   |
Lancia Ypsilon
|
   |
Mazda 2 (Demio)
|
     |
| Mitsubishi Colt |
    |
Nissan March (Micra)
|
   |
Nissan Cube
|
  |
Nissan Note
|
   |
Opel Corsa
|
      |
Peugeot 1007
|
  |
Peugeot 207
|
    |
Proton Savvy
|
 |
Proton Satria Neo
|
  |
| Renault Clio |
    |
Seat Ibiza
|
  |
Skoda Fabia
|
    |
Suzuki Swift
|
    |
| Suzuki SX4 |
   |
Toyota Passo
|
  |
Toyota Yaris / Vitz
|
   |
Toyota bB
|
  |
Toyota Scion xD
|
  |
Volkswagen Fox
|
  |
Volkswagen Polo
|
   |
|
| Performance Mini Cars
(hot hatch) |
|
BMW Mini Cooper S
|
    |
Citroen C2 VTS
|
  |
Fiat Panda 100HP
|
    |
Fiat Punto Abarth
|
    |
Fiat Punto Abarth Esseesse
|
      |
Ford SportKa
|
  |
Ford Fiesta ST
|
  |
Mitsubishi Colt CZT
|
   |
Opel Corsa OPC
|
    |
Peugeot 207 GT Turbo
|
    |
Peugeot 207 RC
|
    |
Proton Twingo TCE
|
  |
Renault Clio RS
|
     |
Suzuki Swift Sport
|
   |
Volkswagen Polo GTI
|
   |
|
Small Family
Cars (C-segment)
|
|
Alfa Romeo 147
|
   |
Audi A3
|
   |
BMW 1-Series
|
   |
Chevrolet Cobalt
|
   |
Chevrolet HHR
|
  |
Chrysler PT Cruiser
|
  |
Citroen C4
|
    |
Daewoo Nubira / Lacetti
|
  |
Dodge Caliber
|
 |
Fiat Linea
|
   |
| Fiat Bravo |
    |
Ford Focus
|
    |
Ford Focus (America)
|
   |
Honda Civic (Europe)
|
    |
| Honda Civic (US / Japan) |
    |
Hyundai Elantra
|
   |
Kia Cerato / Spectra
|
  |
Kia Cee'd / Procee'd
|
    |
Mazda 3
|
    |
Mercedes A-class
|
    |
Mitsubishi Lancer
|
   |
| Nissan Tiida |
  |
Nissan Bluebird Sylphy
|
   |
Nissan Sentra
|
  |
Opel Astra
|
    |
Peugeot 308
|
     |
Proton Gen.2
|
 |
Proton Waja (Impian)
|
 |
| Renault Megane |
   |
Seat Toledo
|
   |
Seat Leon
|
    |
Skoda Octavia
|
    |
Subaru Impreza
|
   |
Toyota Auris / Blade
|
   |
Toyota Scion xB
|
   |
Toyota Corolla
|
   |
Toyota Matrix
|
  |
Volkswagen Golf
|
      |
Volkswagen Jetta
|
    |
Volkswagen Beetle
|
   |
Volvo C30
|
    |
Volvo S40
|
    |
|
| Performance C-segment
(hot hatch) |
|
Alfa Romeo 147GTA
|
   |
Audi A3 2.0TFSI / 3.2 Quattro
|
   |
Audi S3
|
    |
BMW 130i
|
    |
Chevrolet HHR SS
|
  |
Chrysler PT Cruiser Turbo
|
  |
Citroen C4 VTS
|
   |
Dodge Caliber SRT4
|
  |
Ford Focus ST
|
    |
Honda Civic Si (US)
|
    |
Honda Civic Type R (Euro)
|
    |
Honda Civic Type R (Japan)
|
     |
Mazda 3 MPS (Mazdaspeed 3)
|
    |
Mitsubishi Lancer Evo X
|
       |
Nissan Sentra SE-R Spec V
|
   |
Opel Astra GTC
|
    |
Opel Astra OPC
|
  |
Peugeot 308 GT
|
   |
Renault Megane Sport
|
   |
Renault Megane R26
|
    |
Seat Leon 2.0TFSI / Cupra
|
   |
Subaru Impreza WRX (S-GT)
|
   |
Subaru Impreza WRX STI
|
     |
Volkswagen Golf GT 1.4TSI
|
    |
Volkswagen Golf GTI / Ed 30
|
      |
Volkswagen Golf R32
|
     |
|
| Multi-Activity
Vehicles (MAV) |
|
Citroen C4 Picasso / Grand
|
      |
Fiat Idea
|
   |
Fiat Multipla
|
   |
Ford Focus C-Max
|
    |
Honda Stream
|
   |
Honda Edix
|
    |
Mazda 5
|
    |
Mercedes B-class
|
   |
Opel Meriva
|
   |
Opel Zafira
|
    |
Renault Modus
|
   |
Renault Scenic
|
    |
Seat Altea
|
   |
Skoda Roomster
|
    |
Toyota Porte
|
  |
Volksagen Golf Plus
|
   |
Volksagen Touran
|
   |
|
Large Family
Cars (D-segment)
|
|
Brilliance BS6
|
 |
Buick LaCrosse
|
  |
Chevrolet Malibu
|
    |
Chevrolet Impala
|
  |
Chrysler Sebring
|
  |
Citroen C5
|
     |
Daewoo Tosca (Chevy Epica)
|
  |
Fiat Croma
|
   |
Ford Mondeo
|
       |
Ford Fusion / Lincoln MKZ
|
    |
Ford Falcon
|
    |
Holden Commodore
|
    |
Honda Accord (Euro)
|
    |
| Honda Accord (America) |
    |
Hyundai Sonata
|
   |
Kia Magentis (Optima)
|
  |
Mazda 6
|
     |
Mitsubishi Galant
|
   |
| Nissan Primera |
  |
Nissan Altima
|
   |
Opel Vectra
|
   |
Opel Signum
|
  |
Peugeot 407
|
    |
Pontiac G6
|
   |
Pontiac Grand Prix
|
  |
| Renault Laguna |
    |
Saturn Aura
|
    |
Subaru Legacy
|
    |
Toyota Avensis
|
   |
Toyota Allion / Premio
|
   |
Toyota Camry
|
    |
Toyota Prius
|
   |
Volkswagen Passat
|
     |
|
|
|
Acura TSX / Accord (Euro)
|
    |
| Acura TL |
  |
Alfa Romeo 159
|
    |
Audi A4
|
     |
BMW 3-Series
|
      |
Cadillac BLS
|
   |
Cadillac CTS
|
    |
Jaguar X-Type
|
   |
Lexus IS
|
    |
Lexus ES
|
  |
Mercedes C-class
|
     |
Nissan Skyline (Infiniti G)
|
    |
Saab 9-3
|
    |
Volvo S60
|
   |
|
|
|
Affordable
|
Acura TL Type-S
|
   |
BMW 335i
|
      |
Chevrolet Impala SS
|
 |
Chrysler 300C SRT-8
|
      |
Ford Falcon XR6 turbo
|
    |
Ford Falcon XR8
|
   |
| Holden Commodore SS-V |
    |
Opel Vectra OPC
|
  |
Pontiac Grand Prix GXP 5.3
|
  |
Subaru Legacy GT Spec B
|
    |
Toyota Caldina GT-4
|
   |
Volvo S60R
|
  |
Expensive
|
BMW M3 Saloon
|
     |
Holden HSV GTS
|
   |
Lexus IS-F
|
   |
Mercedes C63 AMG
|
      |
|
Executive
Cars (E-segment)
|
|
Audi A6
|
  | |